Sacramento Mayor Kevin Johnson’s signature showed up on a letter to state Sen. Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, expressing support for raising the statewide minimum wage to $13 by July 1, 2017.
And then it didn’t. An announcement from the mayor’s staff said that “staff miscommunication” was to blame for Johnson’s signature on the letter.
What happened? Is Johnson for or against a minimum wage increase? Did he sign the letter or not?
Either way, the discussion should be about negative impacts on employment and income growth caused by minimum wage increases.
The Sacramento Bee reports that Johnson’s signature appeared alongside the signatures of the mayors of Los Angeles, San Francisco, Oakland, San Jose, Santa Ana and Long Beach in the letter sent to Sen. Leno in support of Senate Bill 3.
“Raising the state minimum wage will improve conditions for millions of Californians while at the same time boosting our local economies,” the letter says.
Johnson’s spokesman, Ben Sosenko, said Johnson’s signature should not have been on the letter. But he never said why, other than the rest of the City Council has not taken a position on Leno’s bill, or any other pending legislation. The Business Journal reported individual council members have indicated general support for raising minimum wage in Sacramento, but the council has not specified how the change should be achieved.
California’s minimum wage became $9 an hour July 1, 2014, and will increase to $10 an hour Jan. 1, 2016. Sen. Leno, who believes minimum wage increases impact the “income inequality crisis,” has already tried to inject another minimum increase before Jan 1, 2016, but he failed to get the legislation passed.
In Leno’s home city of San Francisco, San Francisco’s minimum wage is currently $11.05 an hour. But it will jump to $15 an hour by 2018. That increase is forcing Borderlands Bookstore to close its doors. “Borderlands was turning a small profit, about $3,000 last year. Then voters approved a hike in the minimum wage, a gradual rise from $10.75 up to $15 an hour,” ABC 7 reported. “And by 2018 we’ll be losing about $25,000 a year,” the bookstore owner said.
Minimum Wage Increases Hurt Low-Skilled Workers
Despite numerous studies every year showing the damage to low-income communities with minimum wage increases, there is rarely reporting or discussion of the jobs lost in California, as well as the reduction in real output when mandatory minimum wage increases are passed.
Rather than allowing the free market to determine a value of entry level jobs, mandatory minimum wage increases is the way to create a permanent poverty class. The root cause of economic interventions is the mistaken belief that government can improve our lives by making economic decisions for us. By their very nature, economic interventions by government are coercive in nature, Patrick Barron said in There’s No Political Freedom Without Economic Freedom, at the Mises Institute.
“The fact is, the programs labeled as being ‘for the poor,’ or ‘for the needy,’ almost always have effects exactly the opposite of those which their well-intentioned sponsors intend them to have,” American Economist Milton Friedman said. “There is absolutely no positive objective achieved by the minimum wage law. Its real purpose is to reduce competition for the trade unions and make it easier for them to maintain the higher wages of their privileged members.”
Study Shows Minimum Wage Increases Are Detrimental
A study released in December from the University of California San Diego shows that low-skilled workers were the most adversely affected by minimum wage increases; mandated higher wage kills jobs and hurts those it is intended to help.
“We infer from our employment estimates that minimum wage increase reduced the national employment-to-population ratio by 0.7 percentage points between December 2006 and 2012,” the study found. “This accounts for 14 percent of the national decline in the employment-to-population ratio over this period.”
And even more important, unemployment and minimum wage increases appear to be closely linked.
The study shows that between July 23, 2007 and July 24, 2009, the federal minimum wage rose from $5.15 to $7.25 per hour. During this period, the employment-to-population ratio declined substantially–by 4 percentage points among adults aged 25 to 54, and by 8 percentage points among those aged 15 to 24.
Mayor Johnson’s Wage Increase
Mayor Johnson announced in November he would form a task force to explore raising the minimum wage in Sacramento. That task force has not been formed yet, but Sosenko said the issue “is still a priority” for the mayor.
“There’s been no wavering on where he is on this issue,” Sosenko said. “He wants a community discussion and see what works for Sacramento before we get a plan.”
As expected, Labor leaders, are supportive of higher minimum wage rates; any wage increase means more money in their coffers.